| Captains Cup Winners | |
| 1973 | T O'NEILL |
| 1974 | HAVLIN N |
| 1975 | FORRESTER P |
| 1976 | M'QUILLAN P |
| 1978 | FLETCHER N |
| 1979 | M'CORMICK J |
| 1980 | HYNES E |
| 1981 | GLACKIN J |
| 1982 | BYRNE D |
| 1983 | THOMPSON G |
| 1984 | GLACKIN J |
| 1985 | HUNTER J |
| 1986 | FUSCO C |
| 1987 | M'ALISTER J |
| 1988 | CANNING B |
| 1989 | CUNNINGHAM M |
| 1990 | M'ILDOWNEY H |
| 1991 | MOLLOY E |
| 1992 | LAVERY A |
| In 1993 the Dennis Flanagan Cup replaced the Captains Cup as the top prize for the winner of Captains Day | |